Current Employment recently ran an interesting article: “Employers: The LinkedIn Recommendation is Not for You.” The premise of the post is that the reviews that both prior and current employers are leaving for employees on sites such as LinkedIn and Facebook. For employment lawyers, the problem (or the benefit — depending on whose side you are on) immediately jumps out:
Employees get terminated. A lot. And a lot of those terminations are based on performance. As a plaintiffs’ attorney, the best evidence you have of a wrongful or discriminatory termination is documentation establishing that the “pretext” for the termination (the performance problem) is false. Suddenly LinkedIn is in play. Since the vast majority of reviews on LinkedIn are positive, any and all employment lawyers with plaintiff clients should be scouring the site for positive reviews from the same managers that term’ed the employee for “performance” problems.
Tim Eavenson, the author of the Current Employment article sums it up quite well:
This is just the Web 2.0 version of advice that management lawyers have been giving forever – be very careful about praising your exiting employees. I know it sounds harsh, but glowing praise (particularly where it is undeserved) can really be a problem. If an employment case goes to trial, you will be in the uncomfortable position of having to explain to a jury what happened in the hours or days between the writing the amazing recommendation and the time you canned the employee for poor performance.
Tim then poses the question of whether the recommendation feature on LinkedIn is worth anything. He offers several suggestions and I agree: since anyone can make a recommendation, you can get recommendations from co-workers, friends, buddies, company insiders, or anyone else who might have a foot-in-the-door. You can also get recommendations from prominent people you may have not worked but have interacted with: committees, boards, groups, clubs, etc.
The take-away: Employers – be careful; be very careful. Employees – a good-word or a thumbs-up from a respected colleague or member of the community can be the difference between an interview and a resume sent straight to the paper shredder.
As with all social media, the feature works better when more people use it. And I encourage you to do that. When you have a reason to leave a recommendation or describe an experience or if someone requests your assistance, take that request seriously and give some thought into what you write. As more and more employers turn to social media sites for background information on potential employees, this accurate data becomes invaluable.